On the downside, every so often the pond looks outside the incestuous hive mind of the lizard Oz, and discovers there are even worse possibilities out there ...
No, Iran Isn’t Winning the War aka The Iranian Advantage Is an Illusion (*archive link, no guarantee it's working)
Bret Stephens is a doofus of the first water, and therefore in the perfect position to serve as an NY Times columnist ... the rag always has both siderist needs, and Stephens offers the side that's all in on stupidity.
The target for this particular set of insights, and the existential despair they should be feeling, the loss of comfort they're suffering?
Imagine, for a moment, that you are a gifted midcareer intelligence officer in the Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps.
But only imagine that if you can fit it into the complacent mindset of a triumphalist American scribbler ...
It’s a solace of sorts that sophisticated Western commentators think you’re winning this thing. From wherever you are now hiding — since it’s not safe to go to work — it doesn’t feel that way.
This is a man ostensibly writing informed commentary for one of the United States' alleged great newspapers.
Yet somehow his take got old really quick.
As any number of Stephens' readers pointed out - why they subscribe remains a mystery - the Iranian regime's main aim was to survive the war intact. Anything else would be a bonus. They never had a chance to win militarily, but if they get sanctions lifted and get to impose an excise tax on tankers, they'll have an unexpected form of revenue.
Stephens offers the sort of stupidity that allows some Americans to still go around boasting about the many ways they won the 'Nam, Iraq and Afghanistan wars ...
For a moment it almost seemed like he got intimations of his own stupidity:
One insight, repeatedly cited by Western pundits as evidence that Iran has the upper hand in the current war, has led you to its source, a 1969 critique of U.S. policy in Vietnam from none other than Henry Kissinger.
“We sought physical attrition; our opponents aimed for our psychological exhaustion. In the process, we lost sight of one of the cardinal maxims of guerrilla war: The guerrilla wins if he does not lose. The conventional army loses if it does not win.”
This should bring you comfort. It doesn’t.
Imagine you're a completely whacked out opinion columnist for the NY Times, so clueless they can't even take on war criminal Henry's advice
Meanwhile, over in that other place which the pond rarely visits...
Stephen Bartholomeusz
Senior business columnist
Inter alia ...
Qatar’s massive Ras Laffan LNG facility has for instance, suffered significant damage that it says will take two to five years to be repaired. In the meantime, Qatar, which supplies about 20 per cent of the world’s LNG, has lost about 17 per cent of its LNG capacity.
That, like the spike in WTI prices, is good for US shale oil and gas producers, but not so good for US domestic gas consumers– or companies and consumers elsewhere in the world.
It is, of course, conceivable that the ceasefire doesn’t hold and Iran closes the strait again. In any event, the world of oil will never be the same again because Iran has done what it has threatened but never done before and demonstrated its ability to take out a material chunk of the world’s oil supply.
The premium at which WTI traded over Brent could easily become a permanent feature of the market, with oil industry customers, having experienced a deliverability crisis, looking for the security of sourcing their supplies from places other than the now even more volatile Middle East.
Trump, thanks to a war he started, but has yet to provide a coherent rationale for, may have structurally increased, not just global oil prices but US domestic energy prices, raising inflation rates and lowering global and US economic growth rates in the process.
But enough Tootling off the rails and wandering into forbidden pastures.
It's a matter of national and professional pride to make sure a reptile at the lizard Oz can match Stephens' rampant idiocy ... and look who turned up at the bottom of the "news" early this morning ...
The bromancer!
How could the pond turn away the bromancer, especially as he's always been inclined to the triumphalism of a Stephens?
The proud warrior has always been up for a war with China, preferably by Xmas, and is always willing to contemplate bunging on a do, what with war just being a natural extension of politics.
Uh oh ...
The header: Scepticism aside, it’s difficult to see a strategic triumph here for the West; Iran may gain control of the Strait of Hormuz and charge ships $US2m tolls under Donald Trump’s ceasefire deal, despite his claims of achieving ‘total victory’ against Tehran.
The caption for the snap of the mad King: US President Donald Trump has agreed to a two-week ceasefire with Iran. Picture: AFP
The bromancer sounded surprisingly gloomy.
Has his Weltanschauung taken a turn for the worse?:
At first blush, this looks like a good deal for Iran.
Of course it’s impossible to know at this stage how the ceasefire will actually play out because the deal Trump describes, and the deal the Iranian government describes, seem to inhabit wholly different universes.
Trump says the US has won “a total victory, no question”. Iran says it has comprehensively defeated the US and that’s why it’s willing to talk.
One disturbing element is that Trump has said the ceasefire came about because Iran submitted a 10-point plant that is a “workable basis” for negotiation.
Trump didn’t release this
10-point plan. (sic)
Iran did release a version, and it’s full of provisions the Americans couldn’t possibly agree to, such as the withdrawal of all US troops from the region, acceptance of Iran’s uranium enrichment program and payment of reparations to Iran for its war damage.
No one in Iran thinks any of that could ever happen. In the best light, those are just declaratory negotiating positions, but Iranian foreign ministry and national security statements say ships will travel through the Strait of Hormuz under the supervision of the Iranian military.
Even worse, the bromancer talked with petulant Peta and remained resolutely gloomy ... The Australian Foreign Editor Greg Sheridan says if the Iranians control the Strait of Hormuz, they have “won an enormous victory”. “They have withstood the worst that Trump can give, and they haven’t buckled,” Mr Sheridan told Sky News host Peta Credlin. “The Islamic Revolutionary Guard is still in control in Iran. “That is a big victory.”
Despite his desire to disclaim scepticism, the bromancer found a little scepticism went a long way ...
If the Iranians get to charge a toll, they’ve had a huge victory.
We should know what’s happening on that fairly soon.
Trump’s people have briefed the US media that Iran has agreed to give up all its nuclear enrichment activities, including the enriched uranium, agreed to allow fully and free passage through the Strait of Hormuz and so on.
It is not evidence of Trump Derangement Syndrome to treat these claims with extreme caution, if not outright scepticism. During his first term, Trump declared he’d solved the problem of North Korea’s nuclear weapons, that Kim Jong-un had agreed to denuclearise.
That was just flat-out wrong and Pyongyang has continued enlarging its nuclear weapons arsenal and long range missiles.
More recently, Trump announced a detailed peace “agreement” for the Gaza Strip, including Hamas voluntarily disarming, the establishment of a technocratic government for Gaza, a new police force, international peacekeepers and much else.
Almost nothing of that has come to pass.
The reptiles were so desperate to cheer up the bromancer that they flung in a serve of the Bolter ... Sky News host Andrew Bolt discusses the US and Iran agreeing to a two-week ceasefire, which has led to the reopening of the Strait of Hormuz. “Well, shock and surprise, there’s a ceasefire in the Iran war, after just five weeks. Both the US and Iran have agreed to a two-week ceasefire while they talk peace. And the Strait of Hormuz is meanwhile open to oil tankers again,” Mr Bolt said. “Fact is, this ceasefire puts the lie to so much of what you were told by Trump-hating journalists, and politicians, and activists, and assorted experts. Remember how you were told this would be the forever war, how this was a quagmire, how it was Trump’s Vietnam War, with Trump having no plan or offramp, all those predictions which have now been proved wrong.”
There, exactly the sort of triumphalism designed to put the bromancer in a cheery mood - victory is ours Mein Herr... but for some reason the bromancer remained perversely, obstinately in a depressive state.
So while Iran has sustained severe damage, it’s difficult to see a strategic triumph for the West.
Trump has damaged the US alliance structure. A more considered president would have brought US allies with him, at least in some measure.
Trump’s rhetoric has been self-contradictory and increasingly verbally bizarre. Apart from the juvenile scatological references, he threatened that “a whole civilisation will die tonight, never to be brought back again”, presumably by sustained strategic bombing of Iran.
This follows earlier threats to bomb desalination plants.
Quick, a serve of the dog botherer boasting of significant wins.
That should fix up the bromancer ... Sky News host Chris Kenny gives his opinion on the Iran ceasefire. “The ceasefire is due to last two weeks while a permanent settlement is negotiated. Iran has undertaken to open the Strait of Hormuz to shipping,” Mr Kenny said. “So, all in all, with much left to unfold, it appears to be a significant win for Trump and for Middle East security, and the global economy. “We are all used to Trump's wild rhetoric, and we all knew he was attempting to threaten Iran into accepting a deal, but still, the words used by the President, the leader of the free world, yesterday, well, they were shocking.”
Nothing worked, as the bromancer stayed mired in the gloomy mud ...
Anthony Albanese was right to describe them as “inappropriate”. The Prime Minister joined Nationals’ leader Matt Canavan and Liberal frontbencher Andrew Hastie in condemning Trump’s language.
It’s right for political leaders to be careful to avoid needlessly provoking Trump but they are obliged to deal with reality.
Australia is one of the most pro-American countries, yet polls show more than 70 per cent of Australians believe Trump has handled the war badly. A majority of Americans concur.
Previous presidents understood the need to gain public support, at home and among allied countries. Apart from Benjamin Netanyahu in Israel, any allied leader who backs Trump now does so in the face of settled hostility from their own publics.
It’s good that the fighting in Iran has stopped for the moment. But this whole saga still has a long way to run.
Come on bro, it's a new age ... rediscover your inner Cro-Magnon man...
And now for a quick survey of what's lurking in the lizard Oz outside the war in coverage.
Luckily the intermittent archive was working - no guarantee it still is - and that allowed the pond to send off a number of reptiles to that swamp-infested land.
Criticism of Victorian Liberal leadership highlights deeper tensions over strategy, identity and voter drift to One Nation.
By Peta Credlin
The pond usually avoids petulant Peta, and this day it was a good thing, what with it being a bout of navel gazing about Vic Liberals, compleat with the notion that bigoted transphobe Moira Deeming was the way forward.
The pond also had no time for this attempt to lather up EV fear ...
Electric vehicles promise cheaper, cleaner energy and grid support, but hidden costs and unanswered legal questions pose risks.
By Mark Le Grand
It was a pile of alarmist, hysterical tosh, and the pond had to wander down to the credit to work out why ... Mark Le Grand has served for five decades in the law and with various law enforcement bodies.
Arrest those vehicles, seize that grid, come out with your hands up.
The pond also gave this short shrift ...
After ending funding for ACON’s Pride in Diversity, the ABC faces scrutiny over media coverage and ideological influence on reporting.
By Sall Grover
Again the credit gave the game away ...
Sall Grover is the founder of Giggle, a women-only social app, and is a women’s rights advocate.
The pond knows what that code means .. and couldn't even raise a chuckle.
The pond also had to send away Yoni, grinding out a different brand of hysteria, fear and panic ...
Could China deploy Iran’s playbook in the Taiwan Strait? A new report warns the consequences would be catastrophic, especially for Australia.
By Yoni Bashan
North Asia Correspondent
The pond could at least allow this Yoni a teaser trailer ...
Not content with one disaster?
Imagine another ... but don't worry Yoni, the pond is sure the bromancer will start feeling his oats again, and be up for that war with China by Xmas.
Then it was back to the war with a lesser member of the Kelly gang...
The Strait of Hormuz is reopening and markets are cheering. But the Iranian regime is unbroken and its list of demands maximalist.
By Joe Kelly
Washington correspondent
While the pond found a home for Joe at the intermittent archive, the pond found his gloom piquant, down there with the bromancer's, and so worthy of proper treatment ...
His threats to kill off Iranian civilisation were shocking public remarks unbefitting a US president. They will be remembered as a symbol of the changed character of American leadership in the world.
A large grouping of Democrats have used the threat to call for the removal of Trump from office; the MAGA base has fractured.
Trump has also alienated America’s closest allies and taken NATO to breaking point.
Key Iranian figures are already framing the shift towards diplomacy as a major victory.
On Monday, the US President said the Iranian plan was “not good enough”. But as his 8pm deadline shifted closer into view on Tuesday, he seized on it as an opportunity after the intervention by Pakistan Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif.
Iran’s push for a new protocol in the Strait allowing the regime to charge ships up to $2m for safe passage must not be accepted.
It would accede to Iranian extortion in the Strait and see the regime emerge in a stronger financial position with a valuable revenue stream worth billions of dollars each month.
A strong argument can be made that this is a far worse outcome than what existed before the war.
Trump will also need to impose restrictions on Iran’s nuclear program if he is to convince Americans the intervention was worth it.
Preventing Tehran from obtaining a nuclear bomb has become the central justification for and objective of the military campaign.
It is hard to see how Washington and Tehran can bridge their differences on these issues, and US Secretary of State Marco Rubio has consistently played down the likelihood of progress being made through diplomacy.
Both sides are now back to where they were before Trump launched Operation Epic Fury on February 28 – the negotiating table.
The progress of talks over the next two weeks will determine how Operation Epic Fury will be seen.
At this stage, there can be no certainty the final outcome will leave the US – and its allies – any better off.
Sheesh, but all our wars have gone incredibly well, and shown how good it is to be manly in battle ...
The pond was determined to lift the reptile spirits, and then a miracle happened.
The Lynch mob came along to set things right ...
The header: If Iran is not our foe, then what’s the point in having enemies? Too much of the global left want Iran to represent some brave resistance to Western imperialism.
The caption for the lickspittle surrender monkey who lacks the Lynch mob's spine: A demonstrator holds a sign during a protest against US military action in Iran in the Manhattan borough of New York City. Picture: Charly Triballeau / AFP
Huzzah, and in due course the pond will be able to demonstrate that it can match King Donald at doing a weave.
But first please allow the Lynch mob to contemplate the joys of nuking those bloody Islamics ...
The decision to use the A-bomb was not a vexed one. Instead, how to use it consumed the president and his advisers. It was only after Japan’s surrender that Truman wrestled with the ethical implications. The “thought of wiping out another 100,000 people is horrible”, he said. “Killing all those kids” repelled him. “You have got to understand that this is not a military weapon … It is used to wipe out women and children and unarmed people, and not for military uses.”
Donald Trump’s moral struggle over means and ends probably doesn’t match Truman’s. There is nothing in the Democrat’s rhetoric to suggest he wanted to end Japanese civilisation. Indeed, he began its rebuilding. But, like him, the incumbent President has relied on hard power against civilians to force his opponents’ capitulation.
OK, we have a ceasefire with Iran’s depleted leaders rather than their total surrender. But we would be historically myopic not to see how the threat of destruction has resulted in behaviour modification. We would need a deep cynicism to not discern a better future for all those afflicted by Iranian power.
At this point the reptiles flung in snaps of two presidential giants ... President Donald Trump; President Harry Truman
The Lynch mob was all in on history lessons, what with breathtaking comparisons between a world war and a regional carry on ...
Nuke 'em, nuke 'em all, the long, the short and the tall...
In the history of war there is no perfect analogy. Scholars of the Cold War will recoil at a favourable comparison between Truman and Trump. But I think the Iran war is replete with similarities.
An uncouth Trump and pious Truman does not render the 33rd president superior to the 45 and 47th in his transformational power. Indeed, Trump’s war (even if this ceasefire doesn’t hold) almost certainly will not entail the slaughter of Truman’s.
I understand why Trump’s rhetoric has confirmed for many his unfitness for the office he holds. But speaking coarsely while carrying a little stick has resulted in the severe weakening of Iran’s power.
Trump has set back the cause of Iran’s sharia supremacy – the constitutional principle that Islamic law (sharia) has ultimate authority over all state laws, institutions and political decisions in the Islamic Republic. He did this while fighting a war with the goodwill of more Arab allies than any in US history. Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman pushed Trump to make war with Iran, framing the US-Israeli offensive as a “historic opportunity” to reshape the region.
International lawyers have complained at the death of Iranian civilians. We should mourn the loss of innocent lives in any war. But Trump’s violence has killed a fraction of those killed by the regime’s own security forces – more than 40,000 by some estimates.
Dammit, kill all the innocents, it's the only way forward. (And maybe borrow Pontius Pilate's bowl of water and towel, for the washing and wiping of hands thereof)
Then the reptiles had to produce a downer in the form of Rita, lovely meter maid ... Centre of the American Experiment President John Hinderaker says the US “can’t trust” any agreement with Iran. Mr Hinderaker told Sky News host Rita Panahi Iran will “promise,” which cannot be trusted. “They might promise not to seek nuclear weapons or to stop supporting terrorism, but as long as the regime remains in place, they’re going to abandon those promises as soon as they are able.”
Trust the mad mullahs?
Trump chose a nemesis that surely meets every definition of just war. Khamenei made misogyny basic to his rule. His regime denied homosexuality existed, while murdering more than 5000 gay men. His HHH axis – made up of Hamas, Hezbollah and Houthis – targeted civilians in Israel and across the Gulf. Hamas made rape a weapon of war.
If the Iranian regime is not our enemy, we are no longer capable of having an enemy. Too much of the global left want Iran to represent some brave resistance to Western imperialism. The mullahs are not that. Rather than Che Guevara-style guerrillas, these theocrats have controlled for nearly a half-century a state of ancient lineage, to minimal strategic or ideological gain. Their co-religionists deplore them. The Great and Little Satan have combined to assassinate their supreme leader.
Um, so theocracy is the issue?
How about Israel?
If madness while in possession of nukes is a problem, when do we launch a war on North Korea?
The reptiles interrupted with another snap designed to agitate the Lynch mob ... A demonstrator holds a picture of Iran’s Supreme Leader Mojtaba Khamenei in Tehran. Picture: Francisco Seco / AP Photo
And this is where the pond can show the power of the weave ...
Bret Stephens at The New York Times imagined what lower-level officials in Tehran and Mashhad must be thinking: “Your economy: in even deeper crisis than it was before the war, with no turnaround in sight. Your most capable leaders: dead. Your own people: waiting for the war and the state of emergency to end so they can rise against you again.”
You see?
There was the monstrous stupidity and triumphalism of Stephens replicated by the Lynch mob.
The reptiles can produce commentary as dumb as a stick, and more than a match for anything as silly as that emanating from Stephens of the NY Times...
The destruction of Hiroshima and Nagasaki led to the rebirth of Japan. That enemy went on to become one of the freest, wealthiest and closest allies America has ever enjoyed. This was the inauspicious but necessary beginning of a regional transformation. Trump has started his own – at a fraction of the civilian lives lost.
Yes, nuke 'em, nuke 'em all, it's the only way forward to an enduring civilisation.
And so cheap in terms of lives lost. Bargain basement transformation.
Credit where credit is due, because the pond can never resist defaming the University of Melbourne's tattered reputation:
Timothy J. Lynch is professor of American politics at the University of Melbourne.
The long absent lord help his students ...
And so to a footnote and a commendation, though Geoff really should have chambered a larger round ...
That's the best the reptiles could do in their attempt to inflate the tyres of the Canavan caravan?
So much winning.
Dark days indeed ...
And so to turn to the immortal Rowe for the closer ...
It's always in the details, and the pond did like these ...nice tatt ...
Could it get any weirder?
Of course it could ...JD Vance Confronted With Report the Pentagon Allegedly Threatened Vatican with Military Foce.
No couch or pope can feel safe ...