Saturday, April 21, 2012

The gnomic utterances of Chairman Rupert and his minions ...

Why is it that the word 'gnomic' looms large when reading chairman Rupert's tweets? (Never read one? Do yourself a favour here).

'Gnomic utterances' has a long and proud provenance. And while gnomic, the tweets have a certain haiku quality about them.

They call to mind some of the works of Basho:

Summer grass:
all that remains
of warriors' dreams ( a few more here showing how hard haiku is to translate).

Put it another way:

Summer tweets:
all that remains
of proprietor's dreams

Could chairman Rupert have been introduced to the art by Harold Stewart's fine book A Net of Fireflies?

Here's the pond's translation of another one:

Newspapers not so rich:
All struggling
Amazon hurting, etc.

Now we could argue about the use of 'etc' but it adds a certain poignancy. And then there's:

Crappy blogs available
Crappy newspapers unsaleable
Tweeters don't have to buy

You can see why the gnomic Murdoch has at last count some 220,549 followers, and counting. He's the Basho of our times:

Now then, let's go out
To enjoy the snow until
I slip and fall.

And speaking of thousands of crappy blogs, how nice of chairman Rupert to remind us that down under in the twilight glow, it is News Limited that dominates the field.

Where would we, the world, or News be without the crappy blogs provided by Tim Blair, Andrew 'the Bolter' Bolt, Miranda the Devine, Piers 'Akker Dakker' Akerman, or other exponents of the art of crappy blogging etc etc - including the crappiest blog of all, The Punch?

Yes there are thousands of crappy blogs available, and News Ltd provides, as a free community service, the crappiest, most feral, most mindless, most brainless and most offensive of all.

Which is why chairman Rupert's haiku is a sorbet of the spirit and the soul. Make of this one what you will:

HVA first graduation class
Entry by lottery
tragedy for majority losers.

Yes, chairman Rupert has discovered a conscience, and is deeply interested in the Harlem Village Academy.

Will this help get him off the hook next week, when he returns to the Leveson inquiry?

Who knows, but there's sure to be gnomic utterances in abundance as we contemplate Rupert Murdoch and sons: Leveson inquiry becomes a family affair.

Oh okay, it's Saturday, and the pond would do anything, well almost anything, to avoid reading a News Ltd blog. There's Tory Shepherd elevating the tone of the debate at The Punch by calling bullshit all around her - ICB: Freedom of religion vs. freedom from religion - as if the hard-hitting, fearless use of the word 'bullshit' was some kind of QED knockdown argument or proof. When actually all it captures is the tone of argument in a public bar in a Sydney pub ...

Still with my one remaining tooth I bite
My frozen writing-brush that will not write (Buson)

And then there's Miranda the Devine, frothing and foaming and raging away, as in Highway robbery:

What arrogance makes politicians think they have the right to close the busiest road in Sydney for a bike race?

Indeed. One of the most interesting things about schizophrenia is the way someone can rant on endlessly, for hour upon hour about the evils of bicycles, while worshipping at the feet of Tony Abbott, an enthusiastic cyclist. But back to slamming Barry O'Farrell for daring to allow triathetes to use the Harbour Bridge:

Anyway, “The bridge belongs to everybody, not just to motorists.”
New government. Same old war against cars.


Amazingly when a reader told her to get off her bike, that produced this rant:

Seriously what is it with leftards and lies?
Leftards and violence?
Leftards and groupthink?
Leftards and parasiting on others?
Leftards and poor personal hygiene?
Leftards and mind altering substances?
Whats wrong with being a normal clean tidy upright independant truth telling human being?
I believe Anne Coulter has it nailed when she says the demonic left are possesed by the same evil spirit, its all that fits.


You can see how weird it gets in the world of chairman Rupert's blogs, as they begin the campaign to keep Sydney's streets clear of pedestrians, prams, jay walkers, joggers, runners and everyone else engaged in the war against cars. The sort of war that brings New York to its knees for its completely useless marathon ...

Thousands of crappy blogs, carrying messages of stultifying stupidity by obsessives out of touch with any sense of community, angry, harping and bitter, warriors of the keyboard.

It's enough to drive you back to Basho. Here's Stewart's interpretation:

Over the warriors summer grasses wave:
The aftermath of dreams, however brave.

Put it another way:

Over the Devine's blog summer grasses wave:
The aftermath of delusions, however silly.

Oh enough already, we were going to end with an image of a classic lycra-clad lout, the sort that must infest the worst nightmares of Miranda the Devine's dreaming:


Eek, a warrior in the war against cars.

Enough of the nightmare world of crappy Murdoch blogs.

Let's end instead with a plug for Harold Stewart. It shows its age these days, but since it might well have helped give the world Chairman Rupert, champion tweeting haiku poet, it deserves its place in the setting sun.


Between the washing-bowls at birth and death,
All that I uttered: what a waste of breath! (Issa)


Friday, April 20, 2012

Boldly going where no-one at The Australian dares to go ...

(Above: what's the bet he writes for The Australian?)

It was possibly catching a few minutes of Star Trek - The Next Generation (1987-1994) that got the pond going.

There, as brazen as you like, was bald-headed Captain Jean-Luc Picard waving a tablet about, as if he was way ahead of Steve Jobs. It looked like a tablet, it seemed to work like a tablet, and it got the pond's futurist juices flowing. A few minutes later a nonsensical character called Q dropped into the show and that was the end of that. Quick, channel hop time.

But still, the sight of a tablet was funny, and poignant and bold, as appealing as Patrick Stewart's deeply Shakespearian voice.

Next morning, how to dampen the juices?

There was the relentless lizard Oz, at it again, and the target as usual, as always - except when it's climate science - is the NBN:
It takes quite awhile into the story - if you must you can access it here - before you get to the actual quotes on which it's based, by a very careful Telstra CEO David Thodey:

While he stopped short of backing either major party's broadband model, Mr Thodey said a fibre-to-the-node network would be quicker. "There are different technologies to use; they have pluses and minuses on both sides.

"Definitely fibre to the node is a faster and cheaper deployment. However, in some areas the copper has been there for a long time and there could be issues.


And out of that little juggling act, the lizard Oz weaves a header that proposes that doing it quickly, cheaply and nastily is the way to go.

Well the copper out the front of the pond's house has been there for a long time, and damn straight there are issues. Otherwise we'd be using ADSL and still a Telstra customer, and not bleating at all. But do go on:

"If you have a purist view about an ideal world, fibre to the home is definitely the ultimate solution.

So the lizard Oz, if it had wanted to, could have run the exact same story, only with this header:

NBN the ultimate solution:
Telstra CEO David Thodey

In a thousand ways, on a thousand days, that's how skewing the news to suit the editorial agenda works. Distortions, betrayals, choices, and skewerings of the truth of the matter.

And Thodey knows how to deliver the weasel words that suit The Australian:

"But just like when I'm building anything within Telstra, I have to make a good trade-off in terms of the returns I get," he said.

Uh huh. The days when Telstra built anything useful are long gone, which is why it's known as trade-off city.

Ever wonder why The Australian is so insistent in its hostility to fibre, when, as anyone who has the first clue about it, knows it is the "Ultimate Solution" (David Thodey, Telstra)?

Well there's a clue over in Kansas City, which Google is using as one of its fibre internet testbeds, wiring the city in a way that promises thirty times faster web surfing. And a pilot pay-TV service. (Google TV to launch pilot program in Kansas City).

You see, once you've got decent broadband in place, all current bets are off when it comes to delivering audio-visual content, just as all bets were taken off the table in relation to music delivery some time ago.

If Google does move forward with a pay-TV service, don’t expect it to look anything like existing cable or satellite offerings. With its fiber network, Google has the potential to offer an a la carte service that lets consumers choose the channels they want. Expect on-demand services to be heavily integrated as well, just like Verizon’s FiOS TV service. And you can bet that Google will make it dead simple to watch TV on your computers, smartphones, and tablets. (here)

But it's not just on that level that fibre poses a threat to the establishment. If you start to think about the unknown unknowns when it comes to future apps - as futurists are wont to do - then there are already some known clues.

You see the geeks are already working on ways to virtualise networks, which has implications for the likes of Cisco and current hardware - if you want to geek yourself out, head off to Wired, and Mavericks Invent Future Internet Where Cisco Is Meaningless.

Now you might think that it's just a puff piece for untried notions but it's worth remembering that Google back in 2005 built its own networking hardware because it needed to handle high-bandwidth connections between servers ... and for that they needed fibre.

Which is why you can also read about Google's OpenFlow solution to networks, and the new software-defined network it's implemented in Going With the Flow: Google's Secret Switch to the Next Wave of Networking.

Yes the internet is about to go through another series of transformations and transmutations, and fibre is the mechanism for change.

Meanwhile, back in Australia, the lizard Oz is still mounting the case for maintaining copper, along with Malcolm Turnbull, who deep in his heart knows better.

It would be laughable, if it wasn't pathetic. About as pathetic and timid and wretched as Telstra's approach to the internet has been this past decade.

No wonder Amazon is cranking up moves to establish a warehouse base in Australia. (Amazon eyeing off local warehouse in Australia). As the story notes, e-tailing is close to 20% in the United States, a path perhaps made a little easier by the country's long history of mail order catalogues, and Amazon must be pinching themselves every so often when they contemplate the ripe juicy retail market in Australia, which is why they can consider a physical base, despite the small size of the market.

For a long time retail has been at the forefront of "Ijustdon'tgetit-ism" in Australia but you have to say that on the level of newspapers, The Australian has been at the fore of "Ijustdon'tgetit-ism" when it comes to the way the internet is shape-shifting and changing and growing, with implications for any service or product that can be digitised and delivered, or marketed by digital sellers ...

One way or another, fibre will come to be seen as the ultimate solution, and Australia will get there in the end, even if there are hiccups and deviations along the way.

If you wonder why there are luddites willing to oppose the ultimate solution, and continue the embrace of copper, first of all look to their business model.

If it still involves killing trees, or broadcasting over the ether, or delivering signals to proprietary boxes, you're looking at dead technology walking.

Never mind, after the header and the fuss, how did the lizard Oz end its piece?

Telstra would still get payments for migrating customers from copper to fibre, but if that was accelerated under Mr Turnbull's plans, "then there are different cash flows which could be seen as advantageous to Telstra".

Say what? Customers are going to leave copper? Oh no, say it ain't so.

"I have a contract with NBN Co and with the government that stands," Mr Thodey said ...
He emphasised that he was looking forward to the project.

Say what again? Oh and yes, he's willing to negotiate with Mr. Turnbull in the interests of creating value for shareholders. Which is, as it has been for quite some time, very distinct to the business of creating value for customers and for Australia ...

Now that's something The Australian understands ...

(Below: speaking of futurism, click to enlarge this great Chicago-Tribune piece from 1959, found here).


Thursday, April 19, 2012

Getting potty mouthed about potty mouthers mouthing off about potty mouthers ...

(Above: are you sure you want to know more? The bugs might get you).

It's never been exactly clear to the pond why intertubes forums infested by loons exist, or what point they serve.

Take Tory Shepherd - anyone, anyone at all? - and her incisive demolition of Mel Gibson, channeling Joe Eszterhas (he wrote Showgirls for $2m., he must be a genius) in Gibson: Is it time to take pity on the racist potty mouth?

No doubt she meant well. Kick Mel Gibson, call him a racist potty mouth - such a putdown, been working ever since kindergarten - stir the possum, provide a few links, job well done, retire content. The punch-drunk Punch punches on.

And then I swear to the long absent lord, three comments and supplementaries in, you get this from Zeta:

You can get away with anything in Holywood, absolutely anything. You can wake up at 3pm, chase a quart of whiskey with an eightball of blow, bang three whores before sun down, beat your wife, crash your car, and then go to a BDSM orgy in a castle at dawn.

But you can’t be anti-semitic. Even places without rules have to have rules. And you know what? That’s pretty much OK. I mean, you get to work around beautiful people all day, get paid millions of dollars, have even the most boorish and outright illegal behaviour glossed over by multi-million dollar PR execs and all Holywood asks in return, the social contract you sign with them next to the one with your agent, simply says, ‘Don’t be anti-semitic.’ It’s a pretty good deal on balance.

I don’t buy into that whole, Elders of Zion, Ze-Jews-Kontrol-Ze-World bullshit, because they clearly don’t. White men with great teeth and bouncy hair control the world, fact.

But they do control Holywood. Jews have most of the money that gets films made. Offending them needlessly in the place where they live, work, and marry beautiful Eastern European models their mothers don’t approve of is just stupid.

So when Mel Gibson cries about not getting to make more movies in obscure languages, which I’m disappointed in as well, he should just remember he brought this all on himself, by pissing off the only people in Holywood you’re not allowed to piss off.

(edit: it’s highly possible Holywood is actually controled by The Gays, but since we haven’t seen a rush on Elizabeth Taylor biopics yet the jury is still out.)


And then the comeback from Tory Shepherd?

Zeta, I love you, that is all.

Now construe it how you will - as witty satire, as clever insight, as irony of the first water, or as dumb fuck commentary - why was it allowed to stand, and why did Ms Shepherd think it should be allowed to stand? (Is the clue that it's satirical the way Zeta can't manage to spell Hollywood, and instead thinks a play on Holyrood is infinitely funny?)

Was there something deeply ironic about this?

... they do control Holywood. Jews have most of the money that gets films made. Offending them needlessly in the place where they live, work, and marry beautiful Eastern European models their mothers don’t approve of is just stupid.

That's the sort of irony that Oliver Stone and Marlon Brando would love.

Worse follows:

Oh sh*t don’t let AdamC see this, he seems to think they have no real influence over Hollywood even after showing him all the exec’s, casting agents and the original owners of the studios are mainly Jewish.
Glad to see someone else point this out.

Uh huh. Seems like SimonFromLakemba got the message.

It's not a clever satire, it did actually reveal a Jewish conspiracy to run Hollywood. Why I reckon with a bit of time and trouble we could move on to explaining how Jews own the banks and rule the world ...

Now at some point, another ratbag offered up a comment, and this prompted Ms Shepherd to respond:

Sam, please try not to make it personal - we’re about conversation here, not personal abuse.
Why do you think my arguments are stupid or pitiful? Look at the arguments.
There’s really no need to bring my family into it.


Uh huh. Conversation. That'd be the kind of conversation you have when you call people racist potty mouths. So how about Mel Gibson's family? Cue Tedd:

Mel Gibson was inculcated into anti-Semitism by his vehemently self-righteous father Hutton Gibson ...

Yep, leave Ms Shepherd's family out of it, but feel to diss Mad Mel. Oh and the Jews and the Gays ...

And then we head off to la la land, courtesy of one Andy Mack:

wizard, I’ve read some of the Protocols of the Learned Elders of Zion like you recommend and I have come to the conclusion that they are definitely not fake. Here they are ...

And then there's a link to The Protocols of Zion. (Go get the link if you like, but why not a bonus link to Mein Kampf?)

And somehow, thanks to Waz, we land on this:

I personally think that we we’re placed upon earth, rather than having evolved from the African apes.

Somehow he came to that conclusion after reading the comments.

Last the pond looked, the final comment was by Felicity bleeding for Mel:

Gibson was in his own home expressing his own feelings which had nothing to do with any race issue.
The only thing he did wrong was to let a little snake into his home.
Clearly some people want to finish his career off for good.

Conclusion? Well it seems Rupert Murdoch is a Jew, because he owns Twentieth Century Fox and Fox News, and as we know from this little nest of reptiles at The Punch (which Murdoch also owns), the Jews run Hollywood, and they just want to ruin Mel.

Don't believe it? Well, if you head off to the right sort of site, you can read this sort of stuff about Mr. Murdoch, though it's a little out of date when it comes to the NOW:

Owner of Fox TV, New York Post, London Times, News of the World
Probably half-Jewish, on father's side. Seems to identify as Jewish based on
the news bias of his media empire.


Come to think of it, you might see that sort of rambling insight on The Punch any day now. Along with a link to the Protocols of Zion.

As for Sony PE, which includes Columbia and low-rent Tri-Star, and which last the pond checked, was owned by a Japanese conglomerate, remember that the Japanese are in fact closet Jews.

Now all this might come as a slight shock to Mr. Murdoch, who claims to be a Christian, and his wife Wendi a Catholic, and he's been knighted by the Pope, and has said he heads off to church, rather than a synagogue most Sundays ...

But hey, a Jew's a Jew, and remember the Protocols of Zion.

At the end of it all, the pond reeled away, feeling slightly soiled, as one might while dropping in on the local sinkhole.

So what good did Ms. Shepherd's piece do?

Well it flushed out the weirder parts of the readership, but with readers like that, you'd feel like you needed a bar of soap before you headed off into the comments section.

And we learned that somehow Mel Gibson became a major star in a town that hates Mel Gibson and his kind. (Those were the days, why even Cecil B. De Mille could make The Ten Commandments). These days of course for the bigger pictures, Hollywood likes to off-load its risks with European financing. German tax breaks and banks were a big go there for awhile. But remember silly, the Jews control German finance and the banks of the world ...

Figures. The next thing you know they'll be claiming Jesus was a Jew, and so deep down Jews control Christianity ...

So what have we learned today?

Not much. We still need someone to explain why Warner Bros, which was founded by Jews and apparently is in the control of Jews, allegedly turned down Joe Eszterhas's script? Wasn't it Jewish enough? Surely the writer of Showgirls turned in yet another masterpiece full of Jewishness that the Jews of Hollywood would find irresistible? Or does, in an invisible and clever way, Mel Gibson control the "greenlit" button in Warners?

If no one can answer that question without dragging in the Protocols of Zion, perhaps we should just note that writing rhetorical remarks about potty mouths seems only to lead to a condition, a state of being, whereby all must become potty mouthed ...

(Below: click to enlarge, and see how soap can solve the problem 0f monitoring comments at The Punch).

Be careful what you wish for ... you might get blinded by the light.


(Above: go on, make a wish, provided it's a wish that doesn't involve a sense of entitlement, or any return on the taxes you paid the federal government).

Time to go down the rabbit hole again with Jolly Joe.

Reports are arriving from London in which Jolly Joe is quoted as saying Australians will be better off returning to the paddy fields to make a decent living:

Speaking in London, Mr Hockey said that by Western standards the highly constrained public safety net in Hong Kong and other Asian places might seem brutal ''but it works and it is financially sustainable''.

Well it might work for Jolly Joe, but if the long absent lord returned, here's hoping she'll see Jolly Joe shipped to Hong Kong and forced to make a decent living, instead of telling others that their attachment to Medicare arises somehow from a sense of entitlement rather than thinking people should get a fair shake of the raw prawn when it comes to health care.

It gets even better:

''Contrast this with what we find in Europe, the United Kingdom and the United States. All of them have enormous entitlement systems spanning education, health, income support, retirement benefits, unemployment benefits.'' (here)


Contrast this rhetoric with a party that has as one of its highlights an exceptionally generous paid parental leave scheme, enthusiastically promoted by its fearless leader (Angry MPs in Tony Abbott ambush as leave attacked).

Given that his mindset seems to be somewhere back in the eighteen nineties, Jolly Joe probably didn't expect the news of his fearless speechifying to reach down under, what with carrier pigeon and the telegraph slow to deliver the news that supporting education and health shows signs that the peasants are now luxuriating in a sense of entitlement.

And just a little while ago, the question was asked Is Joe Hockey up to the job?

Well if a mindless, pampered, clearly well fed, boofhead headkicker is what's required for the job, Jolly Joe is more than qualified.

''Perhaps the real problem is the exuberant excesses of politicians who do not seem to understand or care about the fact that, like a household, a nation needs to balance its budget over time,'' he said.

Oh go talk to the hand, or perhaps Tony Abbott, and while you're at it remember to fling some more taxpayer money at private schools and the private medical insurers ...

Meanwhile, over at The Punch, Matt Busby Andrews is busy sinking the slipper into Charles Darwin and Richard Dawkins, in Charles Darwin, biologist, botanist and racist. It's the standard sort of rant you expect of The Punch from angry Christians, angry this time that Darwin conformed to conventional Victorian standards when it came to indigenous people.

Andrews gets as far as charging Darwin with setting up the categories of "Social Darwinism" but strangely fails to draw the logical conclusion. Darwin = Adolf Hitler! Could Godwin's Law at last be having an impact?

Anyhow, there was a whiff about the piece - a desire to hang Darwin and his science by any means to hand - and if you can't nail him on the science, then blame the treatment of aborigines in the lucky country on him!

I wuz only doing it m'lud, because Darwin told me so. But weren't you doing it before Mr. Darwin wrote and published his main work? Ah m'lud, before Mr. Darwin, the settlers in Australia treated the aboriginal folk with decency and concern, and we always smiled before we snatched away the land.

Sure enough if you head off to the Sydney Anglicans, there you find a more extended version, with the curiously unpunchy header Darwin, Dawkins and the Law of Unintended Consequences. Yes, Andrews is a senior copywriter but also a member of St. Andrew's Cathedral (here), acting like a stealth bomber at The Punch. So many angry Anglicans, so little time.

The message?

Australia and New Zealand’s academics should have been much more critical of evolutionary thinking – especially as it was applied to every day life.

Actually there's a good case Australians should be much more critical of angry Anglican thinking, at least if they happen to be women and/or gay. Still, it would have been a good stealth bomber routine, if only the Anglicans, always short of copy, decided to cross-publish on the very same day, with bonus quotes and blather, and thereby showed the Anglican fix was in.

The funniest thing then is to jump over to The Drum, pounding away in its bid to get the punters foaming, and read Uthman Badar getting agitated and putting Atheism in the dock. Uthman is the media representative of Hizb ut-Tahrir, a global Islamic political party, determined via exclusively intellectual and political means, to re-establish the Caliphate in the Muslim world.

Naturally he too has a go at atheist bashing.

Has he ever thought about joining the Sydney Anglicans? If he does, Uthman might get some help with his copy and his arguments:

So if the universe is not eternal and could not have come from nothing, the atheist is left with naught but to acknowledge that he or she is without explanation, but not without the faith in science and its ability to possibly provide an explanation at some point in the future. Fine. But is not a reasonable explanation, even if not absolutely conclusive in your mind, better than no explanation?

Say what? Naturally it sent the punters in the comments section into a frenzy, but how can you argue with this sort of sentence?

Negating the existence of God also leaves the atheist with little choice but to adopt secularism and humanism, which are affirmative propositions, requiring positive substantiation, of which nothing rigorous has been presented.

Uthman rounded it out with a flourish - We're all ears, but we're certainly not holding our breath - but by this point the pond had been blinded by the light, revved up like a deuce, at the sight of another runner in the night.

Meanwhile, since we're on a streak, it's truly joyous to discover Paul Sheehan getting agitated about prostitution in Camperdown, the pond's home suburb, in Successful brothel bid would be a stiletto to inner-Sydney's heart.

Sheehan doesn't buy that prostitutes should be dignified as sex workers, presumably because they should continue to be judged as harlots and whores, and driven out, or perhaps turned into pillars of salt. An expanded Stiletto's on Parramatta road will drive a stiletto through the heart of community life in Camperdown, proposes Sheehan from the eerie of his remote life in a Fairfax-funded suburb, seemingly unaware that Camperdown is surrounded by brothels.

Just take a walk along Enmore Road, or south King street, or other bits of Parramatta road, or heck, just use the internet guides available on the intertubes (here for example). There's nothing particularly noble about prostitution, but it happens, and if it happens, it's better happening in a well-regulated (that's to say government-regulated, for benefit of the IPA) environment, and the silly rhetorical flourishes of Sheehan - carping about progressives, as if progressives were responsible for prostitution - belong back in the days when conservatives tried to sweep it under the carpet and pretend it didn't exist.

As it is, the brothels around Camperdown are discreet and don't drive a stiletto through the heart of community life ... as Sheehan might discover if he ever cared to move to Camperdown instead of rabbiting on like a remote landlord determined to screw the renters.

And finally since we mentioned government regulation and the IPA, surely that's a cue to note that Chris Berg is at it again in The Drum, with Sport as propaganda: Bahrain's vile Grand Prix.

Now the pond couldn't care less if there was never another Grand Prix, but what was amusing was the way in the comments section, the punters got agitated about big tobacco being linked to the Grand Prix for years, and the IPA being local apologists for big tobacco. (Remember their scare stories about plain packaging, as in this media release here).

Berg gets very high horse about the Olympics - and yes it's true the pond will not have a single thing to say about the London Olympics:

The granddaddy of international sporting contests, the modern Olympics, has long been a friend of tyranny. Virtually from birth, the Olympics was studiously, and shamefully, neutral about the political environment in its host countries.

Now maybe sport is political, and maybe athletes should never play against athletes from countries run by commies, fascists, dictators and perverts - you know like invaders of Afghanistan and Iraq - but the lesson from the Bergian piece seems to be that columnists living in glass houses shouldn't throw stones, especially if the glass house is sponsored by big tobacco, mining companies out to degut Australian taxation laws, and big business determined to screw workers and consumers.

Now if only we knew who financed/sponsored/subsidised the IPA so we could put those scurrilous rumours to rest, and Chris Berg could maintain his rage about Formula 1 and the Olympics in a purer than pure way ...

Get government out of sport, ban the United States from the Olympics, and get the shadowy private sector sponsors out from under the IPA bed? In your dreams ...

(Below: and since we're now fully blinded by the light, here's an acid flashback to the seventies).

Wednesday, April 18, 2012

Why Cletus Spuckler, ain't you heard, it's a all the fault of the guvvmint ...


(Above: new role models for Sydney bikies).

Things are getting hot in Sydney town as the streets revert to the days of corrupt military officers, convicts and the Rum rebellion (Did it ever leave them?)

There's Daniel Piotrowski getting agitated about violence by punching on at The Punch (and any jokes about being punch-drunk will get you a verbal spray or punch in the moosh) with As bullets shatter windows, let's keep the safety on).

As a sometime gun owner, the pond is bemused. It seems these days the bikies of Sydney have learned how to fire their guns by watching Baz Lurhmann movies, a technique that involves leaping through the air, voiding the front and rear sights, and blazing away. As a result, barn doors seem to be in peril. What happened to the consummate skills on display in the Milperra bikie massacre back in 1984?

And speaking of killing fields, how pleasing it is to see the tobacco industry effectively argue that the government is going to get a material benefit from its plain packaging legislation ... by preventing the tobacco industry from killing people, or packing them off to hospital suffering various forms of grotesque ill-health.

It takes a peculiar form of cheek, right up there with Anders Behring Breivik, to peddle this line, but big tobacco has always found ways to make their business as professional killers seem the quintessence of consumer-caring private enterprise. The language used is frequently pure IPA:

The tobacco companies are also calling for compensation, arguing the Commonwealth is acquiring the valuable advertising space on the packaging for no payment.
They say it is irrelevant that the Government wants to use that space for public health warnings.
Alan Archibald QC, representing Philip Morris, argued the changes crossed a line from regulation to control, saying it "conscripts the cardboard package to the Government's purpose." (here)

Conscription! Why it's worse than the Vietnam days when the government sent innocent country lads off to die in paddy fields. And all the tobacco industry wants to do is help young people to quietly kill themselves.

Roll on plain packaging, and soon enough plain packaged marijuana. Would there be any better way to kill off the drug than to have it available in low dose cigarettes inside boxes full of hideous health warnings? Sometimes the turgid monotony of bureaucrats and government regulation can serve a useful purpose.

And speaking of government regulation and the IPA, what better way to throw to Chris Berg brooding about the Titanic in Regulatory failure of Titanic proportions.

The pond was hoping to avoid any mention of the Titanic. The last few days have been full of a kind of mass hysteria, which shows no sign of abating, because tonight Seven will be launching yet another re-enactment with a two hour slab of suffering.

But back to Berg, who knows his target like the back of his hand, and in a canny recyling move, also managed to get his piece published in The Wall Street Journal, under the canny header The Real Reason for the Tragedy of the Titanic, The disaster is often seen as a tale of hubris, social stratification and capitalist excess. The truth is considerably more sobering.

It's the perfect Bergian IPA analysis, wherein the wrong end of the telescope is used, and so anything of genuine insight or usefulness looks smaller or further away (or so the pond is told, accustomed as it is to using telescopes from the right end, and gun sights to line up a pistol).

There's much Bergian blather through the piece, but it builds to this consummate conclusion:

At the accident's core is this reality: British regulators assumed responsibility for lifeboat numbers, and then botched that responsibility. With a close reading of the evidence, it is hard not to see the Titanic disaster as a tragic example of government failure.

Can anyone anywhere find a better example of a hammer contemplating a world of nails? Your average fair-minded commentator might have seen it as a tragic example of government and private sector failure, but not a dedicated Bergian.

You see, there's no need for the private sector to worry about duty of care or risk management. They shouldn't ever - what never, no never ever - think about the requirements of customers or clients. They should only ever think about the bare minimum they can get away with, or whatever the government regulations dictate, which is why all cars should be built to the quality standards prevailing to the level of the minimum allowed for roadworthiness.

This freewheeling private enterprise way once got the pond in trouble over some cash in the paw payments, but hey, it's the business of the private sector to lie, cheat and create mayhem, and the business of government to try to catch it out, and when it fails, why naturally it's all the fault of the government:

There was, simply, very little reason to question the Board of Trade's wisdom about lifeboat requirements. Shipbuilders and operators thought the government was on top of it; that experts in the public service had rationally assessed the dangers of sea travel, and regulated accordingly. Otherwise why have the regulations at all?

Yep, it was nothing to do with the makers of the Titanic swallowing their own rhetoric about the ship being unsinkable, and then orchestrating a series of catastrophic errors that made it all too sinkable, and so arrive at the point where lifeboats were needed, it was simply that these innocent sheep had put all their faith, trust, hope and perhaps even charity in government regulations, and were badly let down by public servants.

Truly it's an awe-inspiring fit of logic, made even more remarkable by Berg's attempts to get Alexander Carlisle and Bruce Ismay off the hook. It wasn't about cost or aesthetics, it was about conforming to government regulations, and that's why the innocent, hapless capitalists decided to strip lifeboats off the ship. If the government said it was alright, well egad and be damned sir, it must be right ...

For some reason, the pond is reminded of an anecdote at the inquiry when Alexander Carlisle related how he and Harold Sanderson of the White Star Line often merely rubber-stamped decisions made at a meeting by Lord Pirrie and Bruce Ismay with the words "Mr. Sanderson and I were more or less dummies." The head of the inquiry, Lord Mersey replied "That has a certain verisimilitude."

The truth of course is that the truth will never be finally known. Carlisle claimed to have discussed the matter of lifeboats with Ismay, and Ismay denied any discussion of the provisions, and blaming the government was a convenient point of refuge for the private sector then (just as it's been handy ever since). But by golly when a lifeboat was handy, Ismay made use of it ...

Enough already. You can spend meaningless hours brooding on the disaster - amazingly if you want to read the actual inquiries in all their glory you can find them here in full at the Titanic inquiry project.

What the pond would like to do is to apply Bergian logic to the matter of cigarettes and big tobacco.

Now it's well known that tobacco kills people, and that the government, if it's to avoid charges of regulatory failure by Berg and the IPA in the future, should legislate by any means at its disposal to stop cigarettes from killing people - and given the fierce resistance of big tobacco, plain paper packaging seems like as good a way as any to take another step to reducing use of the killer drug.

What chance then of Berg or the IPA writing a story explaining how it's been a failure of government regulation that has allowed killer tobacco to roam the range to date?

What chance of Berg writing a column explaining how the government has set a very low target in terms of regulation - the number of lifeboats so to speak - and big tobacco is merely doing what it is allowed to do by failed government regulations? And deploring this, and perhaps even proposing that cigarettes can only be sold between noon and one on February 29th?

How soon can we see the IPA campaigning for more lifeboats and more effective government regulations in the matter of big tobacco?

Of course if you happen to share Berg's wrong end of the telescope, you'd argue that it's really up to consumers to learn that smoking can kill or badly harm you, and that big tobacco, in hiding the truth about this, was just doing what was right for its business, and that big tobacco has been an exemplary manufacturer of cigarette cruising for centuries, and has always behaved ethically towards its customers ... they might go to the grave sooner, but they go happier.

Or you might think, in a world of risk management, that perhaps an ethical capitalist wouldn't actually manufacture a product well known as a way of killing or injuring the client base.

You might even propose that Institutes that act as apologists for big tobacco are little more than mercenary propagandists of a Lord Haw Haw kind, at which point the pond would have to invoke Godwin's Law ...

Whatever, if you savour a quick drag on a Bergian column, you'll be saved the long slog of wading through the surrealist world view in Alice in Wonderland ... because Chris Berg always manages to evoke Lewis Carroll in the time it once took to have a smoko break.

Once you've had your break, you can march forward into a brave new world, where the private sector will show due care and concern for consumers, unfettered by failed government regulation, and there'll be lifeboats for all ... or at least the number of lifeboats the IPA proposes they can get away with ...

(Below: a regulatory oldie but a goodie).

Tuesday, April 17, 2012

One more time around the mulberry bush kicking the ABC can ...

(Above: a simple test. Which image would you identify with?)

Splendid news and splendid logic in Gerard Henderson's warrior communique from the front lines Left-wing critique of US alliance is a little hit and myth.

It would seem that it was right and proper to head off to Vietnam to get a belting (sssh, be very quiet, don't mention that Australia was on the losing side) because it was a way of tackling a belligerent Indonesia.

In 1965, Australia was genuinely worried about the military designs of the nationalist Sukarno regime in Indonesia. Menzies and others believed that if Australia supported the US in Vietnam, then the US was more likely to support Australia against Indonesian militarism in the region.

End result? No war against Indonesia, a belting in Vietnam, and an invitation to participate in a bloody war in Iraq and a senseless, useless war in Afghanistan.

Yet somehow Henderson contrives to imagine this is a stout-hearted defence of Menzies against the wicked left, who it seems are always banging on about the value of the US military alliance.

Along the way, as is usual for our prattling Prufrock, there needs to be a little gilding of the lily, and so it is with the discussion of a recent ABC documentary:

All the Way also claimed that the Americans forced "conscription on Canberra" because the US wanted more American troops in Vietnam. This is mythology. Conscription for overseas services was introduced in November 1964, well before Australia decided to send combat forces to South Vietnam. Also, as Peter Edwards makes clear in the 1992 official history Crises and Commitments, the prime reason for conscription was to help Britain defend Malaysia against an attack from Indonesia, and to help defend Papua New Guinea.

Let's be kind and assume that there's a typo in the first sentence relating to Australian troops. But how could we be kind about the dating error?

Let's just head over to the National Archives fact sheet for a moment:

The National Service Act 1964, passed on 24 November, required 20 year old males to serve in the Army for a period of twenty four months of continuous service (reduced to eighteen months in 1971) followed by three years in the Reserve. The Defence Act was amended in May 1965 to provide that conscripts could be obliged to serve overseas, and in March 1966, Prime Minister Holt announced that National Servicemen would be sent to Vietnam to fight in units of the Australian Regular Army. (here)

Yes, it was May 1965 that conscripts could be obliged to serve overseas, and by that time Vietnam was front and centre in the federal Liberal government's collective mind.

Sure enough in due course some 63,000 men were conscripted, and some 19,000 served in Vietnam, and while Menzies might have blathered about the deteriorating situation in Asia and in Indonesia, it's extraordinarily disingenuous to pretend the situation in Vietnam had nothing to do with anything.

But then Henderson is never above a little mythologising, in what might be called a mythological counter-mythologising strike, in which in the same breath as mentioning Vietnam, he manages to drag in the Korean War, the Malaysian emergency, and Konfrontation.

It's just another variant on the baleful domino theory doing the rounds at the time, and typical of the hostile "other" world view cultivated of Asia by the Menzies government, which saw Vietnam as a pawn in the Chinese communist end game, when truth to tell the Vietnamese and the Chinese have never been the best of comrades.

The end result? Henderson is still lock step all the way with Julia Gillard and Stephen Smith on Afghanistan:

Successive Australian leaders - with the exception of Whitlam in the early 1970s - have embraced the US alliance because they believed it in Australia's national interest. This was the case in Vietnam. It remains the case concerning Afghanistan.
There were many Vietnamese who supported the US and Australia at the time. Just as there are many Afghans who support NATO's involvement today.


Uh huh. Would they be the ones in Afghanistan on the receiving end of all the moola and worried the drug trade to the States might suffer?

As usual, Henderson sees the dark conspiratorial hand of the ABC in all this, as he tries to work out why Paul Ham's book on Vietnam differs a little in tone from the documentary All the Way:

...there is a significant difference in content and tone between the book and the film, perhaps explained by the fact that ABC staffer and documentary maker Anne Delaney directed and co-wrote All the Way.

Perhaps? Um m'lud, misleading speculation without a shred of evidence. Did the writer speak to the Ham in question, or Ms Delaney before indulging in unfounded speculation?

M'lud: Oh okay, go on.

M'lud, is it not the case that Mr. Ham was both the co-writer and the presenter of the program in question? Is it being a tad silly to suggest that somehow Anne Delaney contrived for Ham to say what he said in the show? Did she use mirrors? Or perhaps a form of hypnosis? Did he speak the unspeakable because he drank tea at the ABC, perhaps with a drugged scone?

M'lud, is it true that, in the days leading up to the program's airdate, the said Ham was out and about beating up the program in the press, as if it somehow contained an accurate guide to his thinking? Like this:

Presenter Paul Ham, author of the book Vietnam: The Australian War, on which the program is based, puts it to us that the Vietnam War was a story of anguish and disillusionment, of misplaced trust and wishful thinking in the name of which our politicians risked the lives of 50,000 young Australians.
The kind of warfare Australia staged in Vietnam was far less macho than that of the Americans, whose behaviour, Ham says, was unnecessarily gung-ho.
"My belief is that we destroyed Vietnam simply because we followed an ally that was lying to us," former private Paul Murphy says.
Ham goes further. "We found ourselves harnessed, not to an American policy but to the American ego." (here, but the paywall might require a google)

Ham goes further?

M'lud, we understand that there was no sighting of Anne Delaney pushing and prodding Mr. Ham to go further in his interview with The Australian.

Enough already. There is of course a simpler, more banal, less paranoid explanation. Ham's book ran some 832 pages in hardback. By the time you get to compressing that kind of monument down into an hour-long television show, you're going to get simplifications, and elisions. As usual, Henderson prefers ideology to pragmatism. Put him on the television documentary with a national interest budget and watch him flounder ...

The rest of Henderson's column is of the familiar kind, displaying his love of Menzies, as celebrated in his famous poem:

There was a Ming sweet and kind
Was never face and spirit and thought and deed so pleased my mind
I did but see Ming passing by
And yet I love him till I die

There's a sideswipe at the Whitlam years - though strangely not a sideswipe at Whitlam's real failure, which wasn't to withdraw from Vietnam, but to dud East Timor - and a few more paranoid flashes:

As a general rule, Australians do not have to check the calendar to learn that it's getting close to Anzac Day. ABC TV and/or radio invariably obliges with a documentary overwhelmingly critical of Australia's involvement in one or more military commitments. This fits with the familiar left-wing line that Australia has fought other people's wars.

But is it a familiar left-wing line? There, after all, is Henderson patiently explaining how important it is that Australia fight in America's wars, so that in due course should we contrive to get in our own war, America might come along and help us out. It is in fact an argument of the warrior class, Henderson division, conducted from the remote eerie behind the lines in the Sydney Institute that we should fight in other people's wars because it might turn out to be politically or ideologically useful.

And with the distinct exception of the second world war, where Australia was directly threatened (let's ignore the talk of the Japanese never wanting to invade, the bombing of Darwin and the submarining of Sydney will do), it's the armchair brigade that have always spluttered and explained how Australian lads need to be up to a barney and can put on a jolly good show. Because if we fight in other people's wars they'll feel the need to fight in ours. What a pity we haven't yet decided to invade New Zealand ...

As for the jab at the ABC, there's also a simpler explanation. You see the show featured Malcolm Fraser, Henderson's bete noir:

Malcolm Fraser, minister for army and defence under Gorton in 1969, explains at some length how the US kept Australia in the dark.

Oh how it must have made Henderson's skin crawl and rush forthwith off to the typewriter.

Never mind, there were a few upsides to the Vietnam war. The dry cleaning trade, and imitation French bakeries have boomed (though there's too much sugar in the baguettes), as has membership of the Vietnamese Catholic church in Australia, and the quality of food has increased exponentially to the point where goi cuon and pork rolls are now considered part of the staple diet. All thanks to Malcolm Fraser acknowledging that bulls in china shops owe an obligation to the ruined lives of people caught up in collateral military and ideological damage.

Whether that offsets the hundreds of thousands of Vietnamese killed, or the continuing to this day entrenched, hard-headed Communist regime is another matter ...

As for the current mess in Afghanistan, Ham also has a few words, and they too don't seem to have been prompted by Anne Delaney at the ABC:

The question is, are we doing it again in Afghanistan? "We fight on in new wars with old allies, still in the dark, still trusting our friends," Ham says.

Oh how could you Mr. Ham. Don't you know that Afghans are totally onside with NATO's involvement today? Sssh, and whatever you do, don't mention the United States when it might be inconvenient, except when blathering on at length about the importance of the American alliance and why we need to be supporting the United States - we mean of course NATO - in its Afghanistan folly, which soon enough will prove that the United States can be as dumb as the Soviet Union ...

The result? Well we'd like to paraphrase Mr. Henderson's concluding par:

There were many Vietnamese who supported the US and Australia at the time. Just as there are many Afghans who support NATO's involvement today.
But you would never know this from viewing the Ham/Delaney documentary All the Way, or many like it.

Yep, there are many Australians who still won't agree that Australia and the United States copped a belting in Vietnam, and seem destined to cop a belting in Afghanistan today.

Poor hapless Stephen Smith in particular seemed almost catatonic and on the verge of an emotional or mental crisis as he tried to explain to Kerry O'Brien why we were still in Afghanistan, and how we were sure to see positive results.

His spinometer machine seemed to have run out of coins (Blood and Honour).

No doubt he wished he was back in Foreign Affairs, rather than defending the dubious ...

But you would never know about any alternatives to current Australian foreign policy by reading Gerard "love Mr. Menzies or leave the country", "all the way with the United States through hell high water and Afghanistan" "fear and loath the ABC in every respect imaginable and possible" Henderson's column today, or the many tedious predictable previous columns like it that have been dumped into the world, often as full as a goog with surplus one-eyed ideology and bonus historical errors ...

(Below: found here).

Sunday, April 15, 2012

Send in the new clowns and chooks to join the ones already here ...


Call me a nostalgic, sentimental doofus, call me old, berate Austrians for having way too much wacky zany time on their hands, say that the intertubes are only good for finding ever more useless ways to waste time, but golly the pond was moved by the imagining of the net search engine in the nineteen eighties, here at mass:werk (make sure your sound is on for the full modem sound blast. Anyone under twenty really shouldn't bother).

But - to try to get juice from trivia - it's also a reminder of the way things have moved apace in the intertubes world, and is a reminder of just why Tony Abbott and his attitude towards providing fast broadband proves he's a regressive doofus of the old school, stuck back in the days of BBSs, and without the first shred of a notion of a clue. And stuck with him are a lot of conservative commentators who really don't get it, and who don't understand the way connectivity is revolutionising the world, and will go on changing it. Including delivery of AV in the way that music is now being delivered by rental services like Spotify.

Speaking of regressive doofuses and of futurism, please allow the pond to call time out and indulge in a domestic spat with commentariat columnist for Fairfax, Paul Sheehan.

They say there's no fool like an old fool, and Sheehan is truly an old fool. But why start off in this abusive way, you ask? Surely the pond should nobly address the issues addressed in Albanese's first-class folly hijacks airport talk.

But what are the issues? Well Sheehan spends the opening pars in his column abusing Anthony Albanese as an extremist who indulges in sneering personal attacks. And then Sheehan proceeds to make a sneering personal attack. So it only seems fair to think the issue is sneering personal attacks and call Sheehan an old fool.

Sheehan blathers on about Albo's breathtaking bluster, and then goes on to a feat of breathtaking bluster that would make even Albl blush. First up, he takes time out to explain that many of the flightpaths to the current Sydney airport fall within Albanese's Marrickville electorate, and goes on to talk about him being compromised. Yes, and once upon a time the Bennelong funnel ran the planes through John Howard's electorate. So what?

And then Sheehan jumps the shark, perhaps fearing that an easy trip from the eastern suburbs to Mascot is about to be snatched away from him:

So ingrained is the lobby against Sydney Airport, so reflexive is the culture of complaint about replacing this precious asset with something far away, it is easy to miss the reason nothing has been done about building a second airport in Sydney despite all the agitating.

You know, there's not a single politician in the current debate that's talking about replacing Sydney airport. There's a lot of talk about complementing or supplementing it with a secondary airport, so when Sheehan talks about hijacking the debate, he does it by example. What a doofus hijacker ...

You'd swear Max Moore-Wilton had scribbled out the text and handed it to Sheehan:

Sydney Airport is an infrastructure jewel, a convenient asset to the great majority of the city's residents, and proximate to the central business district, the source of so much of its patronage. It has significant latent capacity.

An infrastructure jewel? Roll the jaffas down the aisle and remember that next time you try to park, catch a taxi, embark or disembark a plane at Sydney airport. But yes, it's close to Sheehan's address. Oh the ennui of having to trek out to Badgery's Creek.

There's a lot more blather, including this

Significant operating efficiencies have transformed the airport. In the past decade, passenger traffic increased 40 per cent while the noise footprint decreased and the number of aircraft movements rose by just 1 per cent. The phase-in of more Airbus A380 and Boeing 787 aircraft will continue this trend.

Oh yes, the 380s and the 787s are going to make a huge impact on the efficiency of the peak morning and evening shuttle services to various capital cities, especially the Melbourne-Sydney ferry service.

Sheehan blathers on endlessly about how Sydney can double its capacity, and become an antipodean Heathrow. Apparently he hasn't been to Heathrow in recent times, nor does he seem aware that London also has Gatwick and London City airports (and its also serviced by Stansted, Luton, Southend, Oxford, Lydd and Biggin Hill).

What Sheehan doesn't dare to mention, but is the reality, is that to significantly improve Sydney's capacity, the curfew will have to go. But even that won't solve the problems the airport faces during peak domestic times. Nor would re-locating regional airlines, though that will be another adjustment that has to be made in due course.

And then you end up with this bizarre bit of nonsense:

This is why nothing has happened in 50 years. Taxpayers, via their members of Parliament, have opted to make much better use of what they have, rather than spend tens of billions on something for which there is no pressing need.

Taxpayers of course have done no such thing. Their members of parliament have failed the test, a test which interestingly Melbourne passed many years before by establishing its first airport at Tullamarine well out of town (even if the town has now caught up with it), and then by establishing a second airport at Avalon, and now by talking about building a third airport. (Pressure to select site of third Melbourne airport).

Victorians are frequently smug when they hear Sydneysiders yammer on about a second airport, and they can be even smugger because they don't have to suffer Paul Sheehan as a resident fool infesting the pages of Fairfax opinion like a large brown cockroach offering up magic water cures.

And then Sheehan ends up with this:

If the time has come to embark on planning a multibillion-dollar second airport project, the compelling case and the compelling site have yet to converge.
Logic, not inertia, is why Sydney does not have a second airport


That's right. Logic. A three ring circus is dubbed logic. Ye suffering loons ...

The Federal government spent some eight million dollars producing a 3,200 page report presenting compelling commercial reasons - domestic and international - for a second airport - you can get it here in pdf form - and Sheehan in his usual cavalier way tosses his keyboard in the air and says there's no compelling case. As if that's a comprehensive answer.

Of course Sheehan could have spent a little equal opportunity time scribbling about how Barry O'Farrell is off in la la land with his talk about a high speed rail link to Canberra or to Newcastle, as if people flying from Melbourne would want to fly to Canberra and train in to Sydney.

But that's not the loyalist Sheehan way. You have to go elsewhere to discover sense being talked:

For readers not in Sydney or Australia we are not making this up. This fruit cake nuttiness is for real.
In the future as Premier O’Farrell sees it, you will come to Sydney, the global city, via Canberra, where instead of then catching another plane to Sydney, you will catch a train that hasn’t yet been built.
Let’s see. Maybe you won’t fly or even rail on to Sydney. You might just find your business is really in Canberra, global capital of Australia, where corporations have fled to avoid the Sydney lunacy, since Canberra is well connected, not just with government and public administration at a Commonwealth level, but to an interstate flights network or two, as well as to Asia because of the O’Farrell inspired boom in international services Sydney thought were its birthright, because, you know, we’re so important we can do without convenient transport links.
What a circus. (Ben Sandilands, here)


Well every circus needs its clowns, and by golly Sheehan has passed the audition with flying colours.

It's a level of clowning and brazen cheek that could only be matched by a truly consummate player. Come on down Paul Keating, and scribble Airport site is a victim of political expediency for the Daily Terror.

It was of course the Hawke-Keating government that devised the third runway as a way of taking the heat out of pressures being experienced by the airport even in the eighties, and then when Keating took over, he did diddly squat about it. These days Keating likes to blame John Howard for derailing his initiative, but during his time in power he occasionally talked the talk, but he never walked the walk.

Hawke, Keating, John Howard, the federal Liberal and Labor parties, the NSW state Labor party, and now Barry O'Farrell and the current crop of state Liberals ...

No need for lions and elephants, when you can fill a three ring circus full of clowns.

Oh there's a few that can hold their heads up. Gary Punch honourably resigned at the Hawke government's lack of resolution and foresight, but if you want an example of how long a vaudeville routine can endure, have a look at the transcript for a Four Corners program broadcast on the 2nd March 1998, Terminal Folly:

Albanese: What we're left with is a.. is Sydney's er.. aviation problems in terms of satisfying its needs and the need for a second Sydney Airport still there, um... but years in which progress should have been made having been lost.. er.. substantial community opposition to any.. any er.. concerns in terms of fixing the problem er.. are all there, so we've gone backwards, and I think that er.. I think that it is one of the.. the blights on um.. on Bob Hawke, the fact that that's the case.

Yes, yes, Albo, but who opened the third runway? Mr. Punch?

Punch: There's absolutely no doubt. The...the third runway was the beginning of the end for Bob Hawke. It was an expensive price that he paid.

So Paul Keating got to open the third runway as Prime Minister in November 1994. He'd supported the third runway too, but he wasn't branded a traitor to ALP policy as harshly as Bob Hawke was.

Now he gets to write columns for the Terror explaining how he was at one with Badgery's Creek and wanted to go all the way ... except when it came to turning the first sod during his five years in power.

Well we started off by talking about futurism and planning for the future, and we ended up with a gabbling, clucking bunch of Sydney chooks, led by that fine Fairfax fowl Paul Sheehan, and the pond will be long gone before the chooks find a solution.

But we have to hand it to Barry O'Farrell. As the newest chook in the hot seat, he's right up there with Paul Sheehan in delusionary fast train to Canberra chook land ...

(Below: and now since the pond is determined to sort out the matter of WWJD, we've had the suggestion of a hearse, but what about this veeeehikul? Next week WWJF, provided it's agreed Jesus would never fly into Badgery's creek, he'd take a very fast donkey from Canberra).


And now for a little Christian science, evolutionary and big bang theory, along with a proposal to trade in your Volvo for a Datsun 120Y ...

(Above: Click to enlarge Christian science at work. You can get more seventies Spire Christian comics here in pdf form. The page is slow to load but persistence brings rewards beyond imagining).

Usually it being Sunday, the pond would visit the land of the Pellists, but truth to tell, after last Monday's Q&A, the pond is proper right Pelled out.

Is it possible to imagine a superabundance of Pellism so sickly that, like dark chocolate - 70% please - too much richness in the end is too hard to swallow?

Worse, we're stuck with lagged, delayed Pellist insights because they're a week behind at the Sunday Terror - by golly the power of fresh Pellist insights must be a great incentive to buy the rag - so at the moment we're only getting talk about Easter.

Now it's true that this offers some marvellous insights into evolution, in a way certain to put Richard Dawkins and Charles Darwin back in their boxes, just as Pell despatched them to the boundary last Monday:

It is reasonable to believe in the Creator God, unique, spiritual, fantastically intelligent (think of all those mathematical equations and laws which govern the universe), maker of the immeasurable cosmos, which was created through the Big Bang 14 billion years ago.

Indeed. Which is naturally why this Creator God deemed it fit and right and proper to mate with a married woman in the Middle East to produce his only son and heir a couple of thousand years ago.

Why not China? Well they got Confucius ...

This is the Creator God, beyond space and time, who saw life develop from inanimate objects into replicating plants, animals and humans. God saw the development of the human brain and eye, the thumb and forefinger and even more remarkably the voice box, which enables us to communicate our thoughts to one another.

Hang on, hang on, this is beginning to sound suspiciously like intelligent design:

The theory of intelligent design holds that certain features of the universe and of living things are best explained by an intelligent cause, not an undirected process such as natural selection. (here)

Pell sounds like he isn't up to the irreducible and specified complexity nonsense of creationists trading as intelligent designers - wiki here - nor does he bother to explain how god seeing these things resulted in a kind of Picard "make it so" moment (go on, you know you want to watch Picard say it over and over again on YouTube here).

And by golly, Pell is deadset against a thousand monkeys typing for a squillion years to produce the works of Shakespeare:

It is irrational, against reason, to claim something came from nothing. The odds against the world evolving through chance are impossibly high, like claiming a runaway truck through a rubbish dump might produce Michelangelo's Pieta, the statue of the dead Christ with Mary his mother in St. Peter's, Rome.

Indeed. But the odds of the runaway truck being driven by Catholics who chiselled the penis off Michelangelo's sculpture of Bacchus are quite high, suggesting how easy it is for something to turn into nothing, or at least a rubbish dump of ruined once penis-like marble.

And of course if you have a remotest interest in Big Bang theory and singularity, the very first thing you encounter is the notion that at one moment there was nothing, and then there was something - the universe:

Discoveries in astronomy and physics have shown beyond a reasonable doubt that our universe did in fact have a beginning. Prior to that moment there was nothing; during and after that moment there was something: our universe. The big bang theory is an effort to explain what happened during and after that moment. (here)

Only a devoted Pellist could compare Big Bang theories to a truck running rampant through rubbish, or perhaps the Vatican.

The metaphor is so extraordinarily banal and silly that it exemplifies the depths of Pellist thinking. Bury us all in shallow waters before he gets even deeper.

Oh golly that 70% chocolate is so sweet and tasty, especially when you give it a nice orange flavouring.

Now how about conflating religion with physics? Sure thing:

What does go beyond secular reason is to believe this Creator or "Singularity", which we call God, is pure Love, interested enough to send his Son among us.


So god is now singularity. How singular, after fourteen billion years or so, and thousands of years of human evolution, that this singular chap settled on the Middle East a couple of thousand years ago. How to explain this cosmic flash?

Why it's a mere doddle, easy peasy:

That God sent his only Son to live with a human mother in a backward and troublesome province of the Roman Empire 2000 years ago is only a bit more improbable than finding human life on our tiny planet. Despite years of searching for radio signals from space the evidence so far is that we are "Home Alone".

Sheesh. So we're Macaulay Culkin, and god is some kind of combination of Joe Pesci and Daniel Stern? Well that clears everything up ...

But how handy to learn that a belief in god is only a bit more improbable than finding human life (yes cockroaches and mosquitoes you don't count).

Meanwhile, it's true that the hunt for life continues - c.f. Pharyngula's Did scientists discover bacteria in meteorites - but what's amusing is Pell's exceptionalist notion of humanity and life on earth here and now, alone at home, and the way this somehow redeems the absurdity - in a galactic and evolutionary sense - of Christ turning up a couple of thousand years ago.

Yet all who came before him missed out on the chance of going to god because the only path is via Christ. Where's the reasonableness in that? Okay, cue the concept of limbo and purgatory to tidy up the story.

There's another vexing thought. Is Pell content to ascribe a complete lack of imagination to his god?

Surely as a world builder - a favourite sci fi meme - he should be off building worlds and creating life all over the place, seeing as how there's billions of stars and millions of planets on which to come up with something a tad better than humanity.

I mean to set all that in motion and then settle in the Middle East. And also settle for Pellist thinking ....

What a heart-rending lack of imagination.

Meanwhile, over at the Sydney Anglicans, there's a post-Easter lull. We're waiting anxiously on part five of Michael Jensen's epic sins of Sydney series - is a love of dark chocolate only a venial sin?, why has he forsaken us? - because all we have this week is a learned dissertation on what vehicle Jesus might chose should he chose to move amongst us when the rapture comes.

Yes, David Mansfield broods mightily in What Would Jesus Drive? to arrive at this conclusion:

So WWJD?

Would he not have made small sacrifices in motoring comfort and other lifestyle choices for big benefits in mission and compassion to the world he co-created and the men and women he lay down his life for?


Sydney Anglicans, give up delusionary, grasping greedy thoughts of Mercs, Beamers and Rollers. You need to give generously so that homosexuals can be driven out of Africa by dint of missionary effort, and the insidious invasion of the domestic churches by women can be stemmed before it's too late, and Peter and Phillip Jensen are swept away by the matriarchy in all its anti-Timothy heretical forms.

Sadly, it turns out that Mansfield's piece is just the usual bit of rhetoric, designed to come to no real conclusion - who knows WWJD - except the need to make small sacrifices in an Anglican way ...

If only they'd caught up on the news that Cardinal Pell has offered atheists a free trip to heaven provided they're good ... without any need for gathering in cliquey conclaves of Christians or worrying about whether they should trade in the Volvo and buy a Datsun 120Y so the Anglican assault on gays in Africa can continue ...

(Below: atheists in Pellist rapture, the pond is already pre-booked having led a life of exceptional purity and goodness, though there might be a spat at the end of the flight about god being such a Singularly heartless and indifferent and angry goose).